They got a weird-looking cake
When you date someone, you go to great lengths to ensure that they are pleased. Buying them a custom-made cake for their birthday is one of them. This is an excellent way to demonstrate you love them and know their likes and preferences. For example, this woman gave her significant other a cake, but it fell short of their expectations.
First, you could start with the color pallet, which is entirely different from the inspiration image they gave the baker. Second, they requested a basic cake, but what they received was rather complex. Finally, what is up with that frog? It looks like Gollum from the Lord of the Rings.